Apple’s New Ratios

In a surprisingly busy Autumn, Apple have not only announced two new exciting products, but more interestingly – for nerdy designers like myself – also introduced two brand new viewport formats to their ecosystem.

While the iPhone Duo and HomeView aren’t anything new to the wider industry, it’s honestly great to see Apple ‘innovating’ again after years of near identical ratios – roughly 9:20 for phones and 16:10 for MacBooks and iPads. The result for app designers though, and to some extent end-users, is to find out exactly what the ideal use-cases are for these two near ‘square’ products.

HomeView is certainly the simpler proposition, and unfortunately the easier to dismiss – for now restricted to a handful of Apple apps, and anything with video or other forced format (e.g. FaceTime) either brutally cropped or severely letterboxed.

iPhone Duo on the other hand has several quirks, exacerbated by effectively every app being available on it. It’s striking watching the hands-on reviews  just how awkward people’s fingers are trying to grasp such an awkwardly small but wide platform, despite most apps still running in normal ratio with a huge black border.

As Marques points out, many apps will obviously update to fill the extra bar, but some older apps probably never will. Of course, it’s also a question of how you handle the ‘full width’ view when you open the Duo, and this is where it’s an interesting design paradox – you’ve got all this space, but what to do with it?

Calendars, email apps and several similar genres have an obvious answer, as they’ve natively been landscape format on other platforms for years. But what does an iPhone list app do with it? Or a news app? Or Instagram? That’s basically a full redesign – and crucially one that sits somewhere annoyingly just short of what you might do on an iPad or even a web browser.

The long, thin, tall phone screen has been standard for so long that it has almost become the reason apps are the way they are. Responsive design normally deals with different sizes, but this is different. You’re breaking not only the ratio, but having to deal with instantly transitioning between portrait and landscape without making the user experience confusing or disorientating.

As with many paradoxes, hopefully the answer lies in innovation. And coupled with the HomeView, might start to make app designers think outside of the box, or, indeed, rectangles.